Glenogle Viaduct

Rob Roy – Hero or Villain?

The photo shows a section of the Rob Roy Way crossing the old Glenogle railway viaduct, in The Trossachs (to the east of Loch Lomond and just south of the Highland Line). This was almost the cloudiest moment in the four days of glorious sunshine my two friends from America and I had on our hike, not what you might expect in Scotland in early October!  Alongside this, I’ve been reading a fascinating, if intensive, account of the life of Rob Roy by W H Murray.

     Murray’s research aims to prove that RR was not a rogue but an extraordinarily capable man of the glens with a well-tutored upbringing before being faced with the political and religious divisions, especially in Scotland, of late Stuart/Early Georgian England. The scrabble for power and influence left a testy Hanoverian king with a coterie of aspiring and largely self-serving Whig ‘nobles’ prepared to use all methods available to launch and pursue personal vendettas.

     Murray goes to great lengths to show RR primarily as a man of principle and loyalty who behaved like others of the glens but was forced into bankruptcy, homelessness and outlawry primarily by one man, the Duke of Montrose. In this, Murray is seeking to redress the distortions of Daniel Defoe and, later, Sir Walter Scott, who chose to depict RR as something of a loveable but successful rogue rather than the victim of circumstances, pilloried for his skill in evading capture rather than understanding the challenges he faced.

      History, I was reminded, is as much who and what you choose to believe as what you manage to remember!